More Than 150,000 Consumers Subscribe to CHECKBOOK to Find the Best Auto Insurance Companies and More ...

Subscribe to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK for unbiased reports, customer reviews, and ratings on 16 local auto insurance companies.

CHECKBOOK provides:
  • Award winning articles and ratings reports compiled from more than 175,000 Philadelphia (Delaware Valley) area consumer ratings by Consumers' CHECKBOOK and Consumer Reports magazine subscribers who have used these companies and professionals.
  • Thousands of hours of undercover price shopping.
  • Review of complaints received by local consumer agencies such as Better Business Bureau (BBB) and attorney general offices.
  • In-depth research.
  • No advertising.
  • No ballot-box stuffing.
  • Nonprofit
  • Read CHECKBOOK's free advice on choosing a local auto insurance company . Free Article


"CHECKBOOK's strength is its listings, which name names, some undoubtedly in your neighborhood. It suggests which businesses are worth a try — and which, by implication, to treat warily."


"Easy-to-follow charts map out everything from price and reliability to quality of customer service."

I went to them because they were highly rated in Checkbook. The rating is definitely well deserved. When I entered their office for the first time, they had a copy of Checkbook magazine in the waiting room. That shows they pay attention to what their customers think of them.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

Bad work punished. Good work rewarded.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

I am a single, female new home owner with a roof leak that became obvious during our recent major rain storms. Mr. ... gave me an honest opinion on the phone (thought it might not be the roof), came over the next morning to do the estimate, and completed the job a few days later...I feel like a genius for finding him--through Consumers' Checkbook, of course.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

I hired based on previous ratings in Checkbook. Would definitely use again and recommend.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

I just had replacement windows put in. All the firms I contacted were rated well in Checkbook and the firm I picked was fabulous. It's the first place I look if I need something locally.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

Leaves Angies List in the dust.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber

Wonderful service--it's been a lifesaver.

                      A Consumers' CHECKBOOK Subscriber
Previous Next

Name Number of ratings Checkbook's top rating for quality () What percent of customers rated firm "adequate" or "superior" on our survey for "Not unreasonably raising premium as a result of claim(s)" What percent of customers rated firm "adequate" or "superior" on our survey for "Not unreasonably cutting coverage as a result of claim(s)"
1. 21st Century


Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
2. Allstate


800-255-7828
327 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
3. Amica Mutual


800-242-6422
87 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
4. Encompass


Local agent
39 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
5. Erie


Local agent
112 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
6. GEICO


800-861-8380
129 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
7. Harleysville


Local agent
17 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
8. Illinois Farmers


Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
9. Liberty Mutual


800-837-5254
153 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
10. Metropolitan


800-638-2886
14 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
11. Nationwide


877-663-6877
185 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
12. NJM


800-232-6600
83 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
13. Plymouth Rock (High Point/Palisades/Teachers of NJ)


877-725-6423
26 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
14. Progressive


800-776-4737
43 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
15. State Farm


Local agent
512 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
16. The Hartford


Local agent
137 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
17. Travelers


888-695-4625
113 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
18. USAA


800-531-8722
220 ratings Available exclusively to Delaware Valley Consumers' CHECKBOOK subscribers
 Subscribe now for ratings, articles and more.
Sample Subscriber Comments & Reviews for Auto Insurance Companies in the Philadelphia (Delaware Valley) Area
CHECKBOOK provides subscriber comments on their experiences with the firms they use. Please remember that individual subscriber comments are informal. Subscriber comments may give you insight into the types of features and problems that exist in a service field, but are not the best basis for selecting or rejecting a specific firm. To assess the quality of a firm's performance, we recommend that you give more weight to the percentages of favorable ratings. Those percentages are generally based on much larger numbers of consumers' ratings (the number of consumer ratings is noted above).

As You Can See Below, Some Auto Insurance Companies Get High Praise from Their Customers.
Some Others Don't. So Choose Carefully.

Here Are a Few Samples of the Thousands of Comments
CHECKBOOK Has Collected on Hundreds of Different Auto Insurance Companies.

  • Subscriber from BROOMALL, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: This insurance is available only to military service personnel. If you are eligible, you probably..........
  • Subscriber from YARDLEY, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: After 25 years, never a complaint........
  • Subscriber from NEWTOWN SQUARE, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Far exceeded my expectations in timeliness and quality of work. Fast pay at fair price...........
  • Subscriber from DOWNINGTOWN, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Excellent if you are a safe driver. Premiums sky rocket if you have a claim..........
  • Subscriber from YARDLEY, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Outstanding service over many years. They may be a little pricey lately........
  • Subscriber from WASHINGTON CROSSING, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Simply the best!.......
  • Subscriber from AMBLER, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: I have been with Erie Insurance for more than 10 years and cannot complain........
  • Subscriber from PHILADELPHIA, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Their prices are kind of high but service is excellent........
  • Subscriber from PIPERSVILLE, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: Great customer service........
  • Subscriber from PHILADELPHIA, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: We did not inflate the claim (coverage against underinsured motorist), so that may have explained..........
  • Subscriber from WILMINGTON, DE wrote about a local auto insurance company: Car was totaled in an accident but still driveable. Adjuster valued the car higher than..........
  • Subscriber from RICHBORO, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: I was in a car accident and my car was totaled. USAA paid quickly (more..........
  • Subscriber from NEWTOWN SQ, PA wrote about a local auto insurance company: The best........