You Won't Find Anything Else Like Checkbook

  • Nonprofit and independent
  • Takes no advertising or referral fees
  • Ratings and reviews by surveyed Consumers' Checkbook and Consumer Reports local subscribers
  • Undercover price comparisons
  • Complaint counts from local consumer agencies and attorney general offices
  • Advice to help you get the best service and value

Subscribe and see 141 San Francisco Bay Area auto body shops


Page 1 of 114 results
BusinessCheckbook's
Top Rating What is this?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average? What is this?
(Average = $100)
Ratings for Overall Quality What is this?Most Recent Comment
QualityPrice

Hayes Auto Repair

2401 Bush St
San Francisco, CA 94115 415-346-7061

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Let me know upfront how much it would cost and how long it would take. Actually... - May 31, 2024

See all comments

Alioto's Garage

1835 Folsom St
San Francisco, CA 94103 415-864-3022

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Excellent work. Finished on time estimate. - Mar 07, 2024

See all comments

Pierre's Auto Body

1349 9th Ave
San Francisco, CA 94122 415-564-0900

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Their price was enough that my insurance company branded my beloved (but... - Jun 18, 2023

See all comments

Fix Auto Divisadero

1745 Divisadero St
San Francisco, CA 94115 415-865-8450

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Tia who works in the office and is the BEST customer service and Tia who handles... - Nov 14, 2020

See all comments

Don's Auto Body

1270 Bush St
San Francisco, CA 94109 415-673-4700

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Staff is very pleasant and professional to work with. Quality of work is outstanding.... - Feb 18, 2023

See all comments

Parkside Paint & Body Shop

1830 Taraval St
San Francisco, CA 94116 415-661-1135

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
car was totaled and Kevin gave me good information and opinion - Feb 22, 2025

See all comments

European Collision Center

180 12th St
San Francisco, CA 94103 415-551-9700

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Excellent work. Car looks like new. - Mar 05, 2025

See all comments

Charles Henry Company

1540 Bush St
San Francisco, CA 94109 415-673-7900

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Satisfactory. - Oct 14, 2014

See all comments

Fix Auto 17th St

3355 17th St
San Francisco, CA 94110 415-865-8400

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Aaron provided excellent service, provided updates on progress of repairs.... - Apr 21, 2023

See all comments

Selecta Autobody

3730 Mission St
San Francisco, CA 94110 415-282-2665

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
We had two separate accidents for which we went to Selecta. The first one... - Feb 20, 2024

See all comments

West Wind Automotive

351 Valencia St
San Francisco, CA 94103 415-621-6218

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Did a great job of touching up scratches, car looked like new when they finished.... - May 31, 2024

See all comments

19th Avenue Auto Body Center

3950 19th Ave
San Francisco, CA 94132 415-334-5050

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
they completed the repair for lower cost than my insurance estimate, which... - Feb 06, 2022

See all comments

Alioto's Garage II

1970 McAllister St
San Francisco, CA 94115 415-928-0192

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Aliotos is a GEICO repair shop, so their pricing and scheduling is subject... - May 12, 2019

See all comments

Fix Auto San Francisco - Portrero Ave

450 Potrero Ave
San Francisco, CA 94110 415-861-1288

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
No raters have left a written comment.

How we gather (and how to interpret) our data

While even the best body shops can't undo an accident, our ratings reveal that many shops will get your car back on the road without a hitch. But our ratings also reveal that some shops may compound your misery with lousy work.

Because insurance companies pay for most repairs, for most auto body repair customers cost is a less important consideration than quality. But if you’re picking up the tab, how much the shop charges is important.

If your insurance or another party’s insurance will pay for your repair, make sure the insurance company doesn’t cut corners. Your shop can be an expert ally in this effort, but you also must make the right moves.

When your car breaks down or acts up, it’s a major inconvenience—and can be a major expense. That’s why finding a good mechanic or repair shop is so important. Our evaluations of hundreds of area shops will help you find great service and low prices.

Our price comparisons of local auto insurers reveal dramatic company-to-company rate differences—several hundred dollars a year for most consumers, and more than $1,500 per year for many. You don’t have to forsake service for a better rate.

When shopping for insurance, many drivers care about more than just cost, and with good reason: If you have a claim, you want it to paid quickly and get back on the road with minimal hassle. We provide ratings of insurers for claims-handling service.

Unlike the law in most states, California law bars insurers from using factors like credit scores, gender, education, homeownership, and secretive info to set their rates. Instead, companies are required to give the greatest weight in determining rates to three factors: how long you’ve been driving, your driving record, and how much you drive each year. Beyond these factors, companies are allowed to use other factors to set their rates (we describe many of them below), but the average weight of secondary factors must not exceed the weight given to the primary factors in the company’s premium calculations.