Last updated November 2018
Whack! A pebble hits your windshield. Well, in fairness to the rock, it’s more like you hit that poor innocent pebble. But now you have a damaged windshield, which is more than just a cosmetic issue: A cracked window impedes your sightline, and if it fails you’re in even bigger trouble. If your ride’s windshield or windows suffer damage, you want it fixed quickly with little hassle and without overpaying. Read on for help finding a glass act.
Consider a Repair Before Replacing
Damaged auto glass doesn’t necessarily have to be replaced—chips can often be repaired. Modern windshields are essentially made with two layers of glass sandwiching a layer of vinyl, designed so glass breaks into tiny cracks, rather than shattering. These cracks can be filled by injecting polymer into them and then smoothing the area once it sets. Repairs are possible for relatively large areas of damage—larger than you might expect. Generally, chips that penetrate at an angle perpendicular to the surface or at a shallow angle can be repaired. If you’re not sure repair is possible, ask a glass repair shop for an inspection.
Other windows in your car aren’t comprised of the same kind of sandwich; they’re typically “tempered” glass, made by heating it to over 1000°F and then quickly cooling it. This process strengthens the glass and ensures it will break up into very small pieces, which limits injury. If these windows haven’t shattered, they’re also candidates for repairs, instead of replacement.
Small repairs are relatively inexpensive, around $50–$75. But repairs must be made as soon as possible after the damage occurs. Rain and dirt will infiltrate damaged areas over time, and air will quickly make windshield cracks worse, making repair impossible.
Choosing a Shop
While it’s a good idea to get a windshield or other glass repaired as soon as possible, you want to choose a repair shop carefully.
Here at Checkbook.org, you’ll find customer reviews of auto glass outfits. (We regularly survey Checkbook and Consumer Reports subscribers, plus other individuals who we randomly invite to participate.)
If the damage was caused by someone else, and his or her insurance company is paying for the fix, start by checking with the insurer. Some have price agreements with networks of shops and chains, and while they’ll pay for repairs done by others, they might not fully compensate you if you use a higher-priced glass company.
If you’re paying, shop around a bit. Our undercover shoppers collected price quotes from a sample of local shops for four jobs and found it was quite easy. The table below reports the prices shops quoted us. As you can see, we found fairly sizable price differences; for example, from $350 to $797 to replace a cracked the windshield on a 2017 Ford Taurus.
The last column on the table also reports for each shop our price comparison score. These scores indicate how each shop’s quotes, on average, compare to the average price for all shops quoting on the same mix of jobs. The price comparison scores are adjusted so that the average for all shops equals $100. A shop with a score of $110 had prices 10 percent higher than the average shop’s prices; a score of $90 indicates the shop’s prices were 10 percent lower than average.
When collecting prices, also get a timetable for when the shop can get to your car and how long you have to wait after the repair/replacement is done before you drive the car.
Most auto glass services are mobile: They meet you at your home or office parking lot. But you might need to remain parked for a bit after a replacement or repair. How long varies by vehicle, weather, and materials used. For example, cars with passenger-side airbags require either more time or a faster-acting auto glass adhesive because the glass needs additional strength to support the deployment of the passenger-side airbag.
Ask for the warranty details. Look for one that covers the service life of the vehicle—and make sure it covers the glass and labor.
When contacting shops, ask if your technician is certified by the Auto Glass Safety Council (AGSC), which offers training programs and maintains standards for replacement techniques and monitors product performance.
Many auto glass repair shops are members of the AGSC, but any company can employ an AGSC-certified technician. Membership requires the shop to agree to abide by work standards and pass site inspections. These are nice safeguards, but the key is to make sure your technician does great work.
There are three levels of certification:
- AGSC Master Technicians have passed the AGSC master technician certification test and work for AGSC-Registered Member Companies.
- AGSC Certified Technicians have passed the AGSC general technician certification test and work for AGSC-Registered Member Companies.
- AGSC Qualified Technicians have passed the AGSC general technician certification test but do not work for AGSC-Registered Member Companies.
Check on Source of Parts
All automotive glass must meet certain Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, but depending on your vehicle and your insurer, you’ll likely have a choice between replacement glass from the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) or from a different manufacturer that is considered an original equipment equivalent (OEE), or “aftermarket” part.
It makes sense to ask about any cost savings you might get from using an aftermarket glass replacement, but, especially for windshields, it’s usually best to stick with an OEM model. As is the case with other auto body parts, there is some concern over the quality of non-OEM windshields and glass. A lot of aftermarket windshields and windows fit poorly.
Some carmakers—including at the time of this writing Honda, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, and Subaru—publicly recommend OEM replacements. The reason: Beyond structural and airbag support, other new safety technologies rely on windshields. Adaptive cruise control, collision avoidance braking, forward collision warning, lane departure warning, and similar features depend on cameras and/or radar. These manufacturers argue that aftermarket glass might cause errors in these safety systems.
For body repairs, Minnesota law lets you insist that insurers pay for new OEM parts, but that rule doesn’t apply to windshields.
Ask any shop to give you a written promise that all the materials it supplies for your job meet or exceed ANSI Z 26.1 and all pertinent Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards.
Insurance
Auto glass is covered under a policy’s comprehensive coverage. If you don’t have comprehensive coverage on your vehicle, you can’t claim repairs or replacement on your policy. But before you file a claim, find out how much your repair or replacement will cost and compare that to your deductible. It’s not worth bothering to make a claim if it doesn’t substantially exceed your deductible. And even if it does, you may want to pay out of pocket rather than face the possibility of a hefty premium hike.
Many insurers offer “full glass” deductible options, which pay all costs of windshield and window replacements. But don’t buy this protection unless it costs less than $30–$40 per year. Many companies charge a lot more than that, making the cost of the coverage not worth the possible benefit.
Illustrative Prices for Auto Glass Work |
At-home replacement of windshield for 2017 Honda Odyssey | At-home replacement of passenger side rear window for VW Golf | In-shop replacement of windshield for 2017 Ford Taurus |
In-shop repair of 1"-wide chip in windshield | Price comparison score ($100 = average) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ABRA Auto Body & Glass Multiple locations, 888-872-2272 |
$806 | $242 | $389 | $65 | $90 |
| Advantage Auto Glass 680 E Travelers Trl #100, Burnsville, 952-736-9633 |
$942 | $342 | $505 | $50 | $103 |
| American Glass and Mirror 5418 Cottonwood Ln SE #2, Prior Lake, 952-447-3151 |
$313 | $415 | $65 | $100 | |
| Apple Valley Ford Lincoln Mercury 7200 150th St W, Apple Valley, 952-431-5900 |
$1,087 | $529 | $560 | $65 | $132 |
| Auto Glass Express 2179 4th St #2-C, White Bear Lake, 651-494-9252 |
$789 | $191 | $486 | $80 | $97 |
| City Auto Glass 950 W 94th St, Bloomington, 952-767-0000 |
$908 | $221 | $693 | $50 | $102 |
| Fusion Auto Glass Minneapolis, 612-363-3009 |
$950 | $355 | $113 | ||
| Glass Source 7150 Madison Ave W, Golden Valley, 763-545-1800 |
$822 | $213 | $406 | $50 | $83 |
| Glass Today 2597 Cleveland Ave N, Roseville, 651-789-0007 |
$1,087 | $339 | $397 | $79 | $112 |
| Haas Collision & Glass 1400 St Clair Ave, St Paul, 612-470-0415 |
$507 | $60 | $104 | ||
| Harmon Auto Glass 10430 Excelsior Blvd, Hopkins, 952-435-3131 |
$1,065 | $235 | $430 | $30 | $85 |
| LaMettry’s Collision 301 W 77th St , Richfield, 612-866-0016 |
$205 | $385 | $50 | $78 | |
| Lucken Auto Glass 1579 Merganser Ct , Lino Lakes, 952-215-9266 |
$904 | $238 | $391 | $60 | $91 |
| Luther Collision & Glass 9825 56th Ave N, Plymouth, 763-331-6000 |
$342 | $393 | $70 | $105 | |
| Morrie’s Minnetonka Bodyworks 2605 W Wayzata Blvd, Long Lake, 952-543-7830 |
$771 | $202 | $375 | $50 | $79 |
| Only 1 Auto Glass 2001 McMenemy St, Maplewood, 651-789-1111 |
$840 | $335 | $350 | $75 | $101 |
| Onsite Auto Glass 6260 Hwy 10 NW, Anoka, 763-205-2808 |
$890 | $286 | $797 | $90 | $129 |
| Oscar Auto Body 2827 1st Ave S, Minneapolis, 612-871-7052 |
$900 | $231 | $510 | $65 | $98 |
| Ryan & Gordy’s Glass 2134 Vermillion St, Hastings, 651-480-0404 |
$965 | $361 | $370 | $50 | $98 |
| Safelite AutoGlass Multiple locations, 800-800-2727 |
$960 | $439 | $400 | $100 | $126 |
| Shannon Auto Glass 1950 Hastings Ave, Newport, 651-458-0812 |
$751 | $238 | $378 | $40 | $78 |
| Speedy Auto Glass 609 E Grant Ave, Minneapolis, 612-338-2212 |
$850 | $350 | $500 | $50 | $101 |
| Total Glass Professionals 99 5th Ave NW #100, New Brighton, 612-333-7300 |
$796 | $323 | $510 | $75 | $107 |
| Twin Cities Auto Glass 1865 Buerkle Rd, White Bear Lake, 651-328-6830 |
$1,036 | $322 | $407 | $75 | $108 |
| Victory Auto Service & Glass 16326 Hwy 65 NE, Ham Lake, 763-710-8761 |
$288 | $400 | $65 | $96 | |
| Walser Auto Glass 9001 Grand Ave S, Bloomington, 952-884-8884 |
$798 | $244 | $389 | $65 | $90 |