Click below to listen to our Consumerpedia podcast episode on homeowners insurance.

Home insurance companies do not reward loyal customers—long-term customers often pay more than new ones as companies quietly raise rates. (Insurers know most people won’t bother to switch.) Our research found that many policyholders can save more than $500 a year by switching to a lower-priced insurance company; some will save $1,000 or more.

Our researchers worked with two homeowners to collect price quotes for their policies. Costs varied significantly from company to company for the same house and coverage. For instance, our family living in Maplewood would pay $2,051 with Liberty or $2,167 with Allstate, compared to $4,815 per year with State Farm, $6,260 with Country, and more than $7,000 with Amica.

Which companies offer you the lowest rates depends on many factors. In most states, companies are permitted to use credit scores to set their rates. With some companies, a poor-credit penalty more than triples their premiums. Insurers increasingly use other secretive and opaque formulas to calculate what you’ll pay for coverage.

Because pricing methods and premiums can dramatically change over time, shop around for a better rate every few years. But don’t wait until the end of your policy term. If you change insurers, your old company must reimburse you for the unused portion of any payments you’ve made.

What you’ll pay to insure your home depends largely on variables you can’t control, but there are steps you can take—besides shopping for a better rate—to minimize costs:

  • Choose a high deductible.
  • Avoid buying too much coverage or lousy optional protection.
  • Limit the number of claims you make.
  • Consider buying your home and auto policies from the same company. Many offer discounts if you do that. But know that those discounts are usually small and won’t make a high-priced insurer a good deal.

You can choose a low-priced company and still get good claims service. We also report how area policyholders rated their insurance companies for claims-payment service.