A generous federal tax credit, more efficient panels and systems, and eco-conscious homeowners continue to spur interest in residential solar energy.

Although the cost of panels and other equipment has come way down over the last 10 years, the biggest obstacle for most homeowners remains price: For a 5.9 kW system, which would generate all of the electricity needed for a typical house in this area, you’ll have to plunk down about $16,500.

You’ll eventually get your money’s worth. A 26 percent federal tax credit will pay for a chunk of your upfront costs and, over time, you’ll cover the rest by avoiding expensive electricity bills. But the lack of strong local incentives for residential solar projects means Twin Cities homeowners will have to wait longer to recoup their costs, compared to those living in other parts of the U.S. When we ran the numbers for a typical Twin Cities area family with a roof that gets a lot of sunshine, a 5.9 kW system would neutralize their annual electric bills and recoup their solar project costs within nine years.

After that, because their system will provide free electricity for another 10 years—or longer—they’ll realize big profits from going solar: Over 20 years, our example homeowners will come out ahead more than $15,000.

You can finance a solar project purchase to avoid spending savings. Installers offer loans or you can obtain a home equity line of credit.

The payback period and profits from a residential solar installation will improve even more if Congress passes President Biden’s proposal to increase and extend the federal tax credit; as of this writing, Congress was still considering the legislation. Of course, many homeowners simply want to minimize their homes’ impact on the environment, regardless of any cost-benefit calculation. If you are in this group, solar for sure is for you.

No matter your motivations, if you decide to go solar you’ll have to make several decisions, and those decisions will affect how much you’ll spend upfront now, how much you’ll spend over the life of the system, and whether you’re eligible for tax breaks and other incentives.

Start by learning about your options on what to buy, whom to buy it from, and how to calculate potential benefits.

Assess whether your home is a good site for a solar project.

Unfortunately, not all homes are good fits for solar. Most homeowners install rooftop panels. Check the direction of the portion of your roof where you want to install panels. A true-south exposure is best; an east/west exposure may generate 10 to 20 percent less electricity but is still usually worthwhile; the north-facing side of your roof is least useful.

Is your roof shaded by trees or neighboring buildings? If trees create shade, are you willing to remove them? Roughly estimate how many hours of unshaded sunlight this portion of your roof gets each year—obviously, the more the better, especially at the height of the sun’s daily arc.

A 6 kW system will take up about 425 square feet of space on a roof with a direct southward-facing slope.

Don’t worry so much about the angle of the roof’s pitch. A 30-degree angle is best, but installers can adjust panels to an optimal pitch even on a flat roof.

If you’re in a homeowners association or historic district, check what restrictions it may impose on solar panel installations.

Check your roof.

An experienced solar installer can evaluate whether your roof can bear the weight of panels, but it’s worth paying a roofer to spend an hour or so checking it. Click here for our ratings of roofers.

Because solar panels last for 25 years or more, and because your roofing shingles should have equal longevity, ask your roofer if you should in advance replace shingles where you plan to install any system. If your roof is still covered by a manufacturer’s warranty, ask your roofing contractor for written acknowledgment that the installation of solar panels will not invalidate the warranty.

Also consider the roofing materials. Asphalt shingle roofs are most common, and installing the racks that support solar panels on them is fairly simple. Although installers can mount panels on roofs made of other types of material, it’s more complicated and more expensive to put them on clay and concrete tile, slate, and wood or cedar roofs.

Figure out your ideal system size.

It’s important to obtain an accurate calculation of the system size your home needs. Your goal is to install panels that will generate an amount of electricity about equal to what your home uses each year.

It may seem desirable to add as many panels as your roof can support to max out the amount of electricity your home generates. You’d send whatever you don’t use onto the grid, your local utility company would pay you for that electricity, and others would use it, which would reduce use of fossil fuels by local power production plants. But while it might seem nice to operate your own renewable-energy power plant, so far utilities in most states prevent that. Utilities in this area won’t connect to solar projects that are set up to generate more than 120 percent of the electricity needed by their homes.

Because our undercover shoppers found some installers recommended systems that were too large—and more costly—than needed, start by making your own estimate of the system size you need. Check your electric bills for the last year and tally how much power you used and what you paid for it. Don’t just take your latest monthly bill and multiply what you paid by 12. Because electricity usage rises and falls month-to-month, you have to add up the last 12 months of bills to get an accurate accounting. Specifically parse out how much “metered” electricity you used, which is measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh), and the total amount you were charged, which also includes the cost of delivering the electricity to you and other grid overhead expenses, plus taxes. The more electricity you generate and use, the less you’ll pay overall for all these costs, but some charges are unavoidable—you’ll still get billed for any electricity you buy at night, for example.

If you’re planning to buy an electric vehicle in the next few years, add about 2.5kW of capacity per car to your system size.

Next, use a few online calculators to estimate what you need and what’s possible.

  • The PVWatts Calculator is offered by the U.S. Department of Energy National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). It uses your address, geographic coordinates, and details about your energy usage to create its estimates. One drawback of PVWatts is that while it factors in local weather history and variation in solar radiance to tell you how much sun is hitting your rooftop, it doesn’t take into account shade from nearby trees and buildings.
  • Google’s Project Sunroof does measure and factor in shade time, so you should also plug in your info there for a second opinion. Google calculates total hours of usable sunlight per year, the square footage of roof space available for panels, and the kW size of the system necessary to meet your needs. You’ll also get estimates of payback time and key costs.
  • Another good calculator is Solar-Estimate.org. It uses your inputs to estimate recommended system size and output and cost, with or without battery storage; reports available financial incentives and savings; and includes estimates of payback periods with and without financing. But note that when you supply your contact info, unless you opt out, the company will supply it to installers so they can call, text, and email you pitches.

Estimate how long it will take for your system to pay for itself and compare that to how long you plan to stay in your house.

The upfront costs of most solar energy projects are eventually paid back by tax credits and other incentives and lower electricity bills. But that time period is pretty long: For homes with ideally situated roofs in the Twin Cities area, it can be about nine years; if your roof is a less-than-ideal solar candidate, your payback period will be longer.

Using the online calculators listed above, plus tips and resources we describe in this article, estimate how quickly your system will pay for itself—and whether you can live with that. Below we illustrate scenarios for a typical home and family in the Twin Cities area.
 


Homeowners in most other parts of the U.S. can eliminate all their upfront fees by signing on with companies that supply equipment via leases or similar arrangements in exchange for flat monthly fees paid by homeowners. But leasing isn’t yet common in Minnesota.

Although solar panels might improve your home’s selling price, the amount you’ll pay for a system is unlikely to increase the value of your abode on a dollar-for-dollar basis. And because these systems have limited lifespans, the value of the hardware you install will depreciate. If you think you’ll move during the payback period, there’s a good chance that the sale price of your house will not be increased enough by the addition of a solar energy system to offset the cost of installing it. Some buyers might even consider the presence of solar panels an aesthetic negative.

Take other steps to reduce your home’s energy consumption.

Most of our homes unnecessarily waste lots of energy. Often, the combined effects of making inexpensive improvements, adopting better habits, and buying better products will provide large savings.

We detail here 32 changes you can make around your home that will save energy. Several of these tasks cost nothing or nearly nothing to do; others require some upfront spending but quickly pay for themselves with lower utility bills.

Check your homeowners insurance policy.

Make sure it covers solar energy systems. (Most standard policies now do.)