Because homeowners insurance claims are fairly rare, we usually advise consumers to shop for the lowest price and put less emphasis on the quality of claims handling and other service issues. When companies have similar rates, consider service as well as price, especially since many consumers and advocacy groups now report many insurers are paying out inadequate funds to settle claims.

We surveyed policyholders in the seven metro areas where we publish Checkbook and found that most home insurance companies get low or middling ratings from their customers for claims-handling service.

The table belwo reports the percentage of respondents who rated each company “superior” (as opposed to “adequate” or “inferior”) for each question asked on our survey. The companies that scored highest for “overall claims handling quality” were Amica, Armed Forces, PURE, and USAA; the companies that scored lowest were Homesite, Mapfre, Mercury, and Progressive, but many other large insurers received only mediocre ratings.


Our undercover shoppers frequently find insurance agents and sales staff don’t calculate accurate prices, and some offer alarmingly bad information and advice. Agents repeatedly quote wildly incorrect premiums, often more than double the correct amount. And we find some agents and insurance company staff don’t ask enough questions to enable them to quote accurate prices.

Also bad: Many companies and agents push add-ons or increased coverage limits without any discussion or explanation that they’re optional and will increase the premium.

But what really drove our shoppers nuts were agents who told us our requests for price quotes had to be approved by underwriters, and then the agents never followed up. Often, we had to email and call multiple times over several weeks to get information.

To get accurate information and prices, shop several companies and agents. Push hard for reliable information. Determine the exact types and amounts of coverage you want, then make sure the agent bases your premiums on that. Examine price quotes very carefully. If unrequested or unnecessary coverage is included, ask why. If the answer is unsatisfying, take your business elsewhere.

Become a Smarter Consumer Get free, expert advice delivered to your inbox every Wednesday when you sign up for the Weekly Checklist newsletter.