You Won't Find Anything Else Like Checkbook

  • Nonprofit and independent
  • Takes no advertising or referral fees
  • Ratings and reviews by surveyed Consumers' Checkbook and Consumer Reports local subscribers
  • Undercover price comparisons
  • Complaint counts from local consumer agencies and attorney general offices
  • Advice to help you get the best service and value

Subscribe and see 88 Puget Sound area auto body shops


Page 1 of 117 results
BusinessCheckbook's
Top Rating What is this?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average? What is this?
(Average = $100)
Ratings for Overall Quality What is this?Most Recent Comment
QualityPrice

Cook's Auto Rebuild

1722 NE 85th St
Seattle, WA 98115 206-525-7377

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Outstanding for service options and cost. - May 13, 2024

See all comments

Holman's Body & Fender Shop

7301 Roosevelt Way NE
Seattle, WA 98115 206-522-6056

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
They are neighborhood, for me, and ever since they delivered a bid on a job... - Jun 30, 2023

See all comments

Caliber Collision

6218 15th Ave NW
Seattle, WA 98107 206-782-0966

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
I was kept up to date on progress every step of the way. Excellent work. - Feb 29, 2024

See all comments

J & J Collision

517 NW 65th St
Seattle, WA 98117 206-783-3170

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Saved me $1100 compared to next estimate. - Oct 17, 2023

See all comments

Fleury's Collision Center

1484 NW 90th St
Seattle, WA 98117 206-789-6930

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
My Audi took longer than I was told. The owner explained & I believed he... - Aug 08, 2024

See all comments

DeGrazia's Auto Body

12324 31st Ave NE
Seattle, WA 98125 206-440-0559

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Made an appt. weeks in advance for a certain week, but then they didn't... - Oct 08, 2024

See all comments

Metro Auto Rebuild

2218 Airport Way S
Seattle, WA 98134 206-623-6336

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
They worked diligently with my insurance (State Farm) which pays... - Oct 17, 2023

See all comments

Service King Collision Repair Center

1500 SW 107th St
Seattle, WA 98146 206-244-7342

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Months before they would even get to it. - Apr 14, 2020

See all comments

H & I Autobody

317 12th Ave
Seattle, WA 98122 206-324-9262

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
I’m afraid to tell everyone how wonderful they are because it’s... - Jun 03, 2022

See all comments

Caliber Collision

9200 Aurora Ave N
Seattle, WA 98103 206-522-0493

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
First I was taken back on the amount of time to repair the vehicle. Then they... - Oct 11, 2023

See all comments

Gerber Collision & Glass

1110 N 140th St
Seattle, WA 98133 206-363-6050

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
We took our damaged vehicle into their shop. Very nice people. Unfortunately,... - Aug 29, 2016

See all comments

Ballard Collision Carstar

1553 NW Leary Way
Seattle, WA 98107 206-784-3368

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Very pleasant to deal with took a long time with work - May 21, 2024

See all comments

A Plus North Aurora Body & Paint

13720 Aurora Ave N
Seattle, WA 98133 206-361-8098

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Took way too long to complete and pushed back finish date further and further - Mar 27, 2021

See all comments

Gerber Collision & Glass

8753 15th Ave NW
Seattle, WA 98117 206-782-2620

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
No raters have left a written comment.

Werner's Crash Shop

710 Taylor Ave N
Seattle, WA 98109 206-285-0780

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Made the car look like new again. Done on time. Pleasant to deal with. - Nov 28, 2018

See all comments

Fix Auto South Seattle

5958 Corson Ave S
Seattle, WA 98108 206-762-5557

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Weird experience with this shop. Took my car to them a week ago for an estimate.... - Mar 29, 2021

See all comments

Rico's Auto Buff

4623 36th Ave SW
Seattle, WA 98126 206-937-1127

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
The work on our car took quite awhile but it was the insurance companies fault... - Oct 26, 2018

See all comments

How we gather (and how to interpret) our data

While even the best body shops can't undo an accident, our ratings reveal that many shops will get your car back on the road without a hitch. But our ratings also reveal that some shops may compound your misery with lousy work.

Because insurance companies pay for most repairs, for most auto body repair customers cost is a less important consideration than quality. But if you’re picking up the tab, how much the shop charges is important.

If your insurance or another party’s insurance will pay for your repair, make sure the insurance company doesn’t cut corners. Your shop can be an expert ally in this effort, but you also must make the right moves.

When your car breaks down or acts up, it’s a major inconvenience—and can be a major expense. That’s why finding a good mechanic or repair shop is so important. Our evaluations of hundreds of area shops will help you find great service and low prices.

Our price comparisons of local auto insurers reveal dramatic company-to-company rate differences—several hundred dollars a year for most consumers, and more than $1,500 per year for many. You don’t have to forsake service for a better rate.

When shopping for insurance, many drivers care about more than just cost, and with good reason: If you have a claim, you want it to paid quickly and get back on the road with minimal hassle. We provide ratings of insurers for claims-handling service.

You might think that if you’ve been driving for many years without an accident and with few speeding tickets that insurance companies will offer you their best rates. Unfortunately, that’s not necessarily the case.