You Won't Find Anything Else Like Checkbook

  • Nonprofit and independent
  • Takes no advertising or referral fees
  • Ratings and reviews by surveyed Consumers' Checkbook and Consumer Reports local subscribers
  • Undercover price comparisons
  • Complaint counts from local consumer agencies and attorney general offices
  • Advice to help you get the best service and value

Subscribe and see 330 Puget Sound area auto repair shops


Page 1 of 226 results
BusinessCheckbook's
Top Rating What is this?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average? What is this?
(Average = $100)
Ratings for Overall Quality What is this?Most Recent Comment
QualityPrice

South Tacoma Honda

7802 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-472-2300

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
I only use them when the repair can't be done by my regular mechanic. - Mar 03, 2025

See all comments

Titus-Will Ford

3606 S Sprague Ave
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-475-4151

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
I had to have my engine replaced. Fortunately it was under warranty. The... - May 18, 2024

See all comments

Lloyd & Wilson Auto Service

631 S Baker St
Tacoma, WA 98402 253-627-1514

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Kyle and this shop are outstanding. Multiple times have talked to other mechanics... - Aug 15, 2025

See all comments

Titus-Will Toyota

3506 S Sprague Ave
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-475-4155

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Well organized, quick check-in, they kept me informed of what was happening... - Feb 26, 2023

See all comments

Midland Automotive

1624 90th St E
Tacoma, WA 98445 253-531-4331

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
They are very open and upfront on costs and provide great service. this is... - Oct 11, 2024

See all comments

Bitterling's Auto Service

6801 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-472-0415

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Best shop in Tacoma area for advice, reasonable prices, always willing to go... - Mar 19, 2018

See all comments

ROOpair Specialties - Subaru

5205 S Washington St #B
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-475-1760

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
They do Subaru vehicles only. A few years ago, I compared estimates with a... - Apr 02, 2024

See all comments

Zyggi's Auto Shop

3912 S 56th St
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-475-7405

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Fantastic service. Work is done properly and they will not try to add unnecessary... - Apr 15, 2020

See all comments

A & E Automotive Repair & Parts

3201 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-472-3039

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
All of the services and their behaviour or qualities are good. - May 20, 2024

See all comments

Bucky's Complete Auto Repair

6318 6th Ave
Tacoma, WA 98406 253-566-0747

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
When we took our car to Bucky's, we knew it was past due for several maintenance... - Aug 14, 2025

See all comments

Stroh's Automotive Services

4905 128th St E
Tacoma, WA 98446 253-531-5310

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Pessemier's is now owned by Stroh's, but they tell me nothing has changed;... - Jan 04, 2018

See all comments

Precision Automotive & Transmission

3723 6th Ave
Tacoma, WA 98406 253-759-2044

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Professional and honest. I would recommend them to anyone. - Apr 03, 2019

See all comments

Tacoma Dodge Chrysler Jeep Ram

4101 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-475-7300

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Great with cars and prices are good. - May 22, 2024

See all comments

Tacoma Nissan

4030 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-579-1200

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Overall it was a fine experience. But I brought up an issue I was having with... - May 20, 2024

See all comments

Gilchrist Chevrolet Buick GMC

6014 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-474-0645

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
No raters have left a written comment.

Titus-Will Chevrolet

11011 Pacific Ave S
Tacoma, WA 98444 253-539-1000

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Of course they have skilled mechanics and are very professional but going to... - Mar 08, 2023

See all comments

Advanced Auto Care

14708 Pacific Ave S
Tacoma, WA 98444 253-535-1550

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
P They have really nice employees there and they try to help you out... - May 18, 2024

See all comments

BMW Northwest

4011 20th St E
Tacoma, WA 98424 253-922-8700

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
This shop is one of the best I have ever encountered, and I ran an auto shop... - Jan 29, 2025

See all comments

Les Schwab Tire Center

5131 6th Ave
Tacoma, WA 98406 253-756-9699

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
Great customer service. Highly recommend it. Prices are great. - May 20, 2024

See all comments

Dodds Automotive

5642 S Tacoma Way
Tacoma, WA 98409 253-474-9100

Checkbook's Top Rating:
Quality:
?
Price:
?
PriceLower/Higher
than Average?
:
?
Ratings for Overall Quality:
?
?%    
? ? ?
?
?%    
They do safety inspection free. Don't try to sell you work that is not needed. - Sep 11, 2018

See all comments

How we gather (and how to interpret) our data

When your car breaks down or acts up, it’s a major inconvenience—and can be a major expense. That’s why finding a good mechanic or repair shop is so important. Our evaluations of hundreds of area shops will help you find great service and low prices.

While even the best body shops can't undo an accident, our ratings reveal that many shops will get your car back on the road without a hitch. But our ratings also reveal that some shops may compound your misery with lousy work.

Because insurance companies pay for most repairs, for most auto body repair customers cost is a less important consideration than quality. But if you’re picking up the tab, how much the shop charges is important.

If your insurance or another party’s insurance will pay for your repair, make sure the insurance company doesn’t cut corners. Your shop can be an expert ally in this effort, but you also must make the right moves.

Our method of buying a car avoids hassles and yields the best possible price. The key is competition—getting new-car dealers to bid competitively for your business. We tell you how to do it.

Getting a good deal on a car lease is considerably more complex than on a straight purchase, and dealers love this complexity. If you want to lease, you can still initiate a competitive bidding process by nailing down several additional points.